61岁大妈泡温泉在池边跳钢管舞摔倒身亡 ,家属索赔89万,法院咋判的?
这个案件经过了两次判决,一审法院判决,酒店负有30%责任,赔偿死者家属共计30余万元。酒店对一审判决不服,提请了上诉;二审法院撤销了一审判决,重新判定酒店无责任。虽然酒店没有责任,但还是对死者家属,进行了人道主义赔偿,赔偿金额合计148284元。
通过案件宣判,以及酒店善后处理来看,是一个完美结案案件。法院做到了公平公正,不因为死者家属悲痛心情,就同情弱者判定酒店有责任。而酒店被判无责情况下,还能够进行人道主义赔偿,说明这是一家有大爱企业。
事件梳理:大妈泡温泉跳钢管舞摔忘,家属向酒店索赔89万事情发生在云南一位大妈身上,她在退休之后,开始了愉悦的养老时光。虽然年过六旬,却依然青春时尚,学着年轻人一样,拍摄短视频发布到网络平台上。
同姐妹们一起享受退休生活,泡着惬意的温泉,这样美妙时光,怎么能少了短视频记录。在姐妹们提议下,爱美的大妈利用舞池旁钢管,跳起了舞蹈。
看到大妈柔软的身姿,加上漂亮动作,姐妹们称赞不已。在姐妹们欢呼、尖叫声中,大妈表演也越来越卖力,危险性大幅增加。
大妈忽略了泳池危险,也忘记了自己已经不再年轻。大妈没能控制好平衡,让自己在泳池边摔倒,当时就昏了过去。尽管姐妹们及时呼叫救护车,加上酒店应急处理,也没能挽回大妈的生命。
在大妈不幸离开后,其家人将酒店告上法庭。表示酒店没有尽到安全保障义务,加上提醒标识不够醒目,让其承担家人去世责任,赔偿89万余元。
法院经过两次审理判决,做到不偏不倚、公平公正面对家属的诉讼,酒店非常生气,表示自己不应该承担责任。温泉酒店经营过程中,不仅张贴了明显提示,还对浴池边做了防滑处理。大妈的摔倒,完全是自身不注意安全,出现了危险行为,到头来酒店却要为其行为买单。
法院通过了解事情,认定酒店未采取有效防滑措施,做出了一审判决,认定酒店承担30%责任,所有赔偿费用加在一起,合计30万元。
这样一份判决,酒店不能够接受,便提请了上诉。二审法院再次梳理事件,认定酒店经营管理过程中,尽到了提醒和防护义务;且大妈摔倒后,酒店也及时送医救治。基于上面这两点,二审法院决定撤销一审法院判决,重新判定酒店没有责任。
两次判决结果不同,彰显了层级更高法院,在处理案件时候,更偏向于法理,而不是人情。在倩倩个人看来,这份判决公平公正,且非常合理。
酒店处理引人赞,大爱企业受人迎酒店虽然没有责任,但还是对大妈家属,进行了人道主义赔偿。作为一家大型温泉酒店,他们虽然实力雄厚,不差30万元赔偿,但我想他们据理力争的是,自身是否有责任。
整件事情中,大妈作为成年人,明知行为具有危险性而为之,这就是再拿自己生命开玩笑。酒店既有安全措施,又尽到了提醒义务,本就不该承担责任。
法院判定酒店无责后,他们还是愿意,对遇难者家属进行人道主义赔偿,从这里便能够看出,酒店背后的企业,是一家有爱心企业。
有责任赔偿是义务,人道主义赔偿是爱心,两者有着全然不同性质。这样的大妈,不仅害了自己,也给家人和酒店,带来了烦恼。生活中的我们,应该引以为戒,汲取经验和教训。
是《Until you》,中文名《直到遇见你》。《Until you》是Shayne Ward(肖恩·沃德)于2007年11月26号发行的一首情歌,收录于专辑《Breathless》中。
歌词如下:
Baby life was good to me
But you just made it better
I love the way you stand by me
Throught any kind of weather
I dont wanna run away
Just wanna make your day
When you fell the world is on your shoulders
Dont wanna make it worse
Just wanna make us work
Baby tell me i will do whatever
It feels like nobody ever knew me until you knew me
Feels like nobody ever loved me until you loved me
Feels like nobody ever touched me until you touched me
Baby nobody, nobody,until you
Baby it just took one hit of you now I'm addicted
You never know what's missing
Till you get everything you need,yeah
I don't wanna run away
Just wanna make your day
When you feel the world is on your shoulders
Don't wanna make it worse
Just wanna make us work
Baby tell me,I'll do whatever
It feels like nobody ever knew me until you knew me
Feels like nobody ever loved me until you loved me
Feels like nobody ever touched me until you touched me
Baby,nobody,nobody until you
See it was enough to no
If I ever let you go
I would be no one
Cos I never thought I'd feel
All the things you made me feel
Wasn't looking for someone until you
It feels like nobody ever knew me until you knew me
Feels like nobody ever loved me until you loved me
Feels like nobody ever touched me until you touched me
Baby,nobody,nobody
It feels like nobody ever knew me until you knew me
Feels like nobody ever loved me until you loved me
Feels like nobody ever touched me until you touched me
Baby,nobody,nobody
Nobody,nobody,until you
Shayne Ward - Until You 直到遇见你
Baby life was good to me.But you just made it better
宝贝.生命一向待我不薄.但你让它更加美好
I love the way you stand by me Throught any kind of weather
我喜欢有你相伴.陪我渡过风风雨雨
I don't wanna run away. Just wanna make your day
我不想逃离. 只想让你幸福
When you feel the world is on your shoulders
当你感到肩负世间重担
Don't wanna make it worse.Just wanna make us work
我不会把它变更糟.只想让我们更顺利(交往)
Baby tell me I will do whatever
宝贝.告诉我.不管什么事我都会去做
[Chorus] It feels like nobody ever know me until you knew me
没有人像你那样了解我
Feels like nobody ever love me until you loved me
没有人像你那样爱我
Feels like nobody ever touch me until you touched me
没有人像你那样感动我
Baby nobody, nobody,until you
宝贝.没有人.没有人...只有你!
Baby it just took one hit of you now I'm addicted
宝贝.一遇见你.我就沉溺其中
You never know what's missing Till you get everything you need,yeah
如果你不曾拥有.你不会知道失去.喔~~
I don't wanna run away. Just wanna make your day
我不想逃离. 只想让你幸福
When you feel the world is on your shoulders
当你感到肩负世间重担
Don't wanna make it worse.Just wanna make us work
我不会把它变更糟.只想让我们更顺利(交往)
Baby tell me I will do whatever
宝贝.告诉我.不管什么事我都会去做
It feels like nobody ever know me until you knew me
没有人像你那样了解我
Feels like nobody ever love me until you loved me
没有人像你那样爱我
Feels like nobody ever touch me until you touched me
没有人像你那样感动我
Baby nobody, nobody,until you
宝贝.没有人.没有人...只有你!
See it was enough to know If I ever let you go.I would be no one
看吧.显而易见.如果我离开了你.我将不复存在.
cause I never thought I'd feel All the things you made me feel
因为我没想过你会给我如此感觉
Wasn't looking for someone until you
直到遇见你.才让我不再寻寻觅觅
It feels like nobody ever know me until you knew me
没有人像你那样了解我
Feels like nobody ever love me until you loved me
没有人像你那样爱我
Feels like nobody ever touch me until you touched me
没有人像你那样感动我
Baby nobody, nobody
宝贝.没有人.没有人...只有你!
It feels like nobody ever know me until you knew me
没有人像你那样了解我
Feels like nobody ever love me until you loved me
没有人像你那样爱我
Feels like nobody ever touch me until you touched me
没有人像你那样感动我
Baby nobody, nobody,until you
宝贝.没有人.没有人...只有你!